Sediment quality standards: are they needed in Flanders
at the moment?
Deckere, E.D., W.D. Cooman, V.V. Weesenbeeck and P.
Meire
University of Antwerp, Department of Biology, Universiteitsplein
1, 2610 Wilrijk, Belgium
Abstract
Almost nine years
ago the Flemish Government initiated the development of a monitoring
tool for sediment quality. This finally resulted in the year 2000
into a routine monitoring network based on a Triad approach, in
which 150 locations are sampled each year with a recurrence every
four years.
In the beginning, there was a lack of good sediment
quality guidelines, but it was decided to use the geometric mean
of the concentrations of the different contaminants found at five
locations. These five locations were located in relative undisturbed
areas and during a first classification no ecotoxicological effects
were observed and the biological quality was good. Since then these
quality guidelines have been slightly changed by increasing the
number of the "reference" locations to twelve. Currently,
these sediment quality guidelines will be further founded by an
intensive evaluation of the results of the 640 sampling locations
that were already sampled.
Now the question rises whether these sediment quality
guidelines have to be formalised into standards. This would give
the government an extra tool to urge water managers to do an effort
for the ecological restoration of the sediments. However based on
hydraulic and nautic requirements in the Flemish streams there is
at the moment a need for the removal of approximately 28 million
m3. Due to the high contamination of these sediments, which are
regarded as waste, the destination options are limited and the removal
becomes very expensive. The introduction of in-situ standards will
increase the amount of sediment that has to be removed tremendously
and thus also the costs. Therefore, it seems better to introduce
well-founded sediment quality guidelines, which are not used as
standards. In this way the government can invest more money in the
prevention of the high input of sediments and contaminants.