| |
|
Methods for assessing the toxicological significance of metals
in aquatic ecosystems: bio-accumulation-toxicity relationships,
water concentrations and sediment spiking approaches
U. Borgmann
National Water Research Institute, Environment
Canada, 867 Lakeshore Road, P.O. Box 5050. Burlington, Ontario,
Canada L7R 4.46
|
Abstract
Although the published literature abounds with studies
showing contamination of aquatic environments by metals, there are
very few data which actually demonstrate the biological impact of
this contamination. Biological impacts such as alteration of in
situ communities and demonstration of toxicity in environmental
samples often occur at sites with elevated metal concentrations,
but this does not prove that metals are actually responsible for
these effects. Correlation is not proof of cause and effect. Metal-induced
biological effects cannot usually be inferred from measured environmental
concentrations because metal bioavailability can vary dramatically
from site to site. Differences in metal bio-availability lead to
differences in metal bioaccumulation, which in turn lead to differences
in metal-induced effects. On the other hand, metal concentrations
in biota are often much better indicators of potential biological
impact tan concentrations in the environment, because differences
in metal bio-availability are automatically taken into account.
Measurement of the body concentration of metals is a powerful tool
for predicting metal effects, especially for non-essential and non-regulated
metals. The body burden approach is more limited when applied to
essential metals such as copper and zinc. Alternate methods which
provide useful information on metal bioavailability, especially
for copper and zinc, include measurement of metals in the overlying
water during sediment toxicity tests, and sediment spiking with
additional metal. Canadian Crown Copyright © 2000 Published
by Elsevier Science Ltd and AEHMS. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Sediment toxicity tests; Bioassays; Benthic invertebrates;
Copper; Zinc; Lead; Cadmium
|