| |
Exemptionalism vs environmentalism: the crucial debate on
the value of ecosystem health
J. Cairns Jr*
Department of Biology, Virginia
Polytechnic Institute and State University Blacksburg, VA 24061,
USA |
Abstract
The concept of exemptionalism holds that human society
is exempt from the biophysical laws that control other species because
of human ingenuity, technology, creativity and economic systems.
Some economists believe that resource depletion is irrelevant because
alternative resources will be developed if there is enough demand
backed by money. A related statement is that any problem created
by technology can be resolved by technology. Within these frames
of reference, ecosystem health is of minor, arguably no, importance
to the exemptionalist.
The concept of environmentalism views Homo sapiens as
just another biological species that is tightly controlled by biophysical
laws, but which is able to modify the biophysical laws more than
other species. This view acknowledges human society's dependence
on ecological life support systems and the services they provide
and assumes that the well being of human society is closely linked
with the health of natural systems. Only within the Inter framework
will ecosystem health be a major concern of human society. ©
1999 Elsevier Science Ltd and AEHMS. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Sustainable development; Carrying capacity; Sustainability;
Biophysical taws
|